Permanent Christmas lights are easy to love. You put them up once, nobody climbs a ladder in November, and you don’t have a box of lights to haul back to the garage in January. For many Wisconsin homeowners, that convenience makes them an appealing option.
The trade-off is how much time those lights spend outside. Permanent lights stay on your house year-round, while seasonal Christmas lights are exposed to the weather only during the Christmas season. At Cloute, we install, service, take down, and store seasonal Christmas lights through a three-year plan, so we see the seasonal side of the comparison.
In this guide, we’ll walk through the trade-offs of both approaches, what can happen when lights need repair, and the questions worth asking before you commit. If you’d rather have a crew handle the whole process, learn more about our Christmas light installation in Fort Atkinson.
Why Homeowners Choose Permanent Christmas Lights
Homeowners choose permanent Christmas lights for convenience. The lights go up once, so nobody climbs a ladder every November, and there is no box of lights to store every January. For a busy household, that is a real draw and a fair reason to consider them.
The bigger trade-off is what happens after installation day. A permanent system stays on the house year-round, which means the lights are exposed to months of sun, storms, winter weather, and everything else that comes with being outside in Wisconsin.
| Permanent Christmas Lights | Seasonal Christmas Lights | |
| Stays installed | Year-round | Christmas season only |
| Annual installation | No | Yes |
| Off-season storage | No | Yes |
| Weather exposure | Year-round | Seasonal |
| Repairs | Depends on system/warranty | Cloute services its installed display |
| Cloute installs | No | Yes, on a three-year plan |
What Does Year-Round Exposure Mean for Permanent Christmas Lights?
One of the biggest differences between permanent and seasonal Christmas lights is simply how long they stay outside. Permanent lights stay on the house through every season, while seasonal lights are installed for the Christmas season, then taken down and stored.
That longer exposure does not automatically mean a permanent system will have problems, but it does mean the lights spend more time dealing with outdoor conditions.
Summer Weather Still Matters
Permanent Christmas lights stay in place through sun, humidity, thunderstorms, and hail, even during months when they are not in use. Seasonal lights avoid much of that exposure because you take them down after Christmas.
Animals Can Be a Factor
Squirrels and other animals can also damage exterior wiring and materials. A system that stays outside all year simply gives them more opportunity to get to it than one that is installed for a shorter season.
We have seen that difference firsthand. One set of lights left up year-round on a home failed within a year. That is one example, not a prediction of how every permanent system will perform, but it is part of why we prefer taking seasonal lights down and storing them once Christmas is over.
What Happens When Permanent Christmas Lights Fail?
What happens when permanent Christmas lights fail depends on the system. With some products, a problem may affect more than the individual section that stopped working. Others are designed so a single section can be replaced. That is worth understanding before you buy.
Warranties deserve a close read too. A product warranty may cover replacement lights without covering the labor to reinstall them, and that labor can add up even when the lights themselves are under warranty.
Questions to Ask Before Buying Permanent Christmas Lights
If permanent lights still sound like the right fit for your home, ask a few questions before you commit. The answers can help you understand what ownership may look like after installation day.
- Partial failure: Can a failed section be replaced on its own, or would a larger portion of the system need to be replaced?
- Warranty labor: Does the warranty cover reinstallation labor, or only the replacement lights?
- Service calls: How quickly can someone come out if part of the system stops working, and what does service cost after the warranty ends?
- Wisconsin track record: How has the system performed on other Wisconsin homes through summer storms and winter weather?
Clear answers make it easier to compare the long-term commitment of permanent lights with a seasonal plan.
How Does Cloute’s Three-Year Seasonal Christmas Light Plan Work?
Our seasonal plan runs for three Christmas seasons, and we own the lights throughout the plan. Each fall, we install them on your home. After Christmas, we take them down and store them at our shop until the next season. That means the lights spend only part of the year exposed outside.
What Happens When a Section Stops Working?
If part of your display stops working, call us. Our goal is to have someone at your home within 24 hours. Because we own and service the lights, we can cut out the failed section and replace it without starting over with the entire display.
When the next three-year cycle begins, we replace the old lights with a new set.
Can You Change Your Display During the Plan?
Yes. If you decide you want a different color in year two, we can make that change for an additional charge. Because we store the lights at our shop, some of the work can happen there before installation day.
What Does Christmas Light Installation Cost?
Cloute prices Christmas light installation by the linear foot, so the cost depends largely on the size and shape of your roofline. Wreaths, trees, shrubs, and any lift access needed for the job are priced separately.
A single-season installation costs more per season than the three-year plan because the lights are purchased and used for only one season. For actual planning ranges and a closer look at what affects the price, see our guide to how much Christmas light installation costs.
Should You Choose Permanent or Seasonal Christmas Lights?
The right choice depends on what you want from your display. If you want lights that stay in place year-round and remove the need for seasonal installation, permanent Christmas lights may be a good fit. The questions above can help you understand what comes with that convenience before you commit.
Cloute installs seasonal Christmas lights, so naturally that is the approach we know best. We prefer the seasonal model because the lights spend less time exposed outside, and our team handles the installation, service, takedown, and storage for you.
If you like the idea of professional Christmas light installation without storing lights or climbing a ladder every year, seasonal Christmas lights may be the better fit for your home.
Planning Your Christmas Light Installation
November is our busiest month for Christmas light installation, so planning early gives you the best chance of getting the date you want. Last year, our latest installation was around mid-December, though late-season availability always depends on the schedule.
Because Christmas lights clip into your gutters, it is a good idea to make sure they are cleaned out before installation day. If your gutters are due for a cleaning, ask us about pairing that service with your Christmas light installation.
When you are ready, call us at (920) 563-4101 or schedule a free estimate. We’ll talk through the look you want, the areas you want to light, and what makes the most sense for your home.
Frequently Asked Questions About Permanent Christmas Lights in Wisconsin
Every roofline, property, and budget is a little different, so the best choice can vary from one home to the next. Here are some of the questions homeowners ask most often.
Q. Do permanent Christmas lights hold up better than seasonal lights in a Wisconsin winter?
A. In our experience, seasonal Christmas lights tend to hold up well because they are outside only during the Christmas season. Permanent lights stay exposed year-round, and their long-term performance depends on the system, installation, and service options.
Q. What happens when permanent Christmas lights stop working?
A. It depends on the system and the warranty. With some systems, a failure may require replacing more than the section that stopped working. A warranty may also cover the replacement lights without covering the labor to reinstall them, so it is worth asking about both before you buy.
Q. How often do seasonal Christmas lights get replaced on a three-year plan?
A. On our plan, we use the lights for three Christmas seasons. When a new three-year cycle begins, we start with a new set. Because we own and service the lights, we can also cut out and replace a failed section during the plan.
Q. What does a three-year seasonal Christmas light plan include at Cloute?
A. Our standard plan includes design, installation, service during the season, takedown after Christmas, and storage at our shop. Cloute owns the lights throughout the plan and handles them from one season to the next.
Q. How fast can you fix seasonal Christmas lights that stop working?
A. Our goal is to have someone at your home within 24 hours of your call. Service on the installed display is included in the plan.
Q. Can I change my Christmas light colors during the plan?
A. Yes. You can change colors during the plan for an additional charge. Because we store your lights at our shop, some of the preparation can happen there before installation day.
Q. How late can I book Christmas light installation in Fort Atkinson?
A. November is our busiest month, and last year our latest installation was around the middle of December. Late-season availability depends on our schedule, so planning early gives you the best chance of getting the date you want.
Q. How much does Christmas light installation cost?
A. Cloute prices Christmas light installation by the linear foot, so the cost depends largely on the size and shape of your roofline. Wreaths, trees, shrubs, and lift access are priced separately. A single-season installation costs more per season than the three-year plan. Our Christmas light installation cost guide has planning figures.